Bug on route reflection with BIRD (no originator ID on withdrawals)

[Vasileios Kotronis]

Hello there,

I am facing an issue with a route reflection setup on BIRD.
I have the following setup:
external router --(eBGP)--    monitor
                                              | (iBGP)
                                              |
                                              reflector
                                              | (iBGP)
                                              |
                                              client

The reflector reflects routes from the monitor (monitoring the external
router via BGP) to the client. However, I notice that the originator ID
(used for loop detection in a RR setup) is input by the  BIRD RR only in
announcements, and not in withdrawals. This means that if the same
withdrawal (from the monitor) propagates within the RR cluster there is no
way to disambiguate this from another withdrawal. According to RFC4456 (
https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc4456):

ORIGINATOR_ID

   ORIGINATOR_ID is a new optional, non-transitive BGP attribute of Type
   code 9.  This attribute is 4 bytes long and it will be created by an
   RR in reflecting a route.  This attribute will carry the BGP
   Identifier of the originator of the route in the local AS.  A BGP
   speaker SHOULD NOT create an ORIGINATOR_ID attribute if one already
   exists.  A router that recognizes the ORIGINATOR_ID attribute SHOULD
   ignore a route received with its BGP Identifier as the ORIGINATOR_ID.
Also:
If a route carries the ORIGINATOR_ID attribute, then in Step f)
      the ORIGINATOR_ID SHOULD be treated as the BGP Identifier of the
      BGP speaker that has advertised the route.

So, since RFC4456 is fully supported in BIRD, shouldn't this be present
both in route announcements and withdrawals?

This is my simple BIRD configuration (I am running version 2.0.10):
log syslog all;

router id 192.168.55.4;

protocol device {
}

template bgp rr_clients {
  local 192.168.55.4 as 50414;
  neighbor as 50414;
  rr client;
  rr cluster id 1.0.0.1;

ipv4 {
import all;
export all;
};

ipv6 {
import all;
export all;
};
}

protocol bgp monitor from rr_clients {
neighbor 192.168.55.3;
}

protocol bgp client1 from rr_clients {
neighbor 192.168.55.2;
}

Thanks in advance!

Best regards,
Vasileios

-- 

Vasileios Kotronis

CTO & Co-founder
www.codebgp.com

Monitor • Detect • Protect
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://trubka.network.cz/pipermail/bird-users/attachments/20221213/33a5212c/attachment.htm>