Multi-protocol core

Martin Mares mj at ucw.cz
Mon Oct 3 12:59:52 CEST 2011


Hello!

> >Why is it called MPLS, when we call all other configuration switches
> >CONFIG_something?
> I thought CONFIG_XXX relates to protocol support and general features is
> defined like IPV6, without any prefix.

IPV6 is a rather special case, in the retrospect I think it should have
got the CONFIG_ prefix, too.

> >Calling this beast "vpn" without further clarification is going to be
> >confusing -- people (even those experienced in networking) usually do not
> >associate "vpn" with "MPLS" implicitly. Better choose a more descriptive name.
> Well, VPN prefix is heavily used in rfc 4364, for example. I'm a bit
> out of ideas. "mplsvpnv4" is more specific, of course, but a bit
> long.

Maybe keep the name, but explain it in a comment.

> >| +  unsigned int addr_type;		/* Type of adresses stored in fib (IPv46, VPNv46, MPLS, etc..)*/
> >| +  unsigned int addr_size;		/* size of address specified in entry */
> >| +  unsigned int addr_off;		/* value of data offset to be set in fib_node */
> >
> >I did not understand anything from the latter two comments.
> >
> >What is specified in an entry? An address? Or the size itself?
> It specifies size of address data used in particular fib (e.g.
> addr_size = sizeof(ip_addr)).
> 
> s/size of address specified in entry/Size of address data/ ?

OK.

> >Offset of which data?
> Address data from the previous comment.
> 
> s/value of data offset to be set in fib_node/Address data offset in
> fib_node/ ?

You should explain that it is an offset from the start of the structure.

> >Instead of that, set f->hash_f during initialization of the FIB according to
> >the type of addresses used.
> Thanks, as a result:
> If we do hash_f setting in FIB init and assume non-IP users to set
> their own hashing function fib_hash can be changed to simple:
> 
> #define fib_hash(f, a)		(f)->hash_f(a)

Yes.

				Have a nice fortnight
-- 
Martin `MJ' Mares                          <mj at ucw.cz>   http://mj.ucw.cz/
Faculty of Math and Physics, Charles University, Prague, Czech Rep., Earth



More information about the Bird-users mailing list